Andrew Goodwin was a media theorist and practitioner who spent years analysing the music industry and music video production, in order to put together a set of key features that apply to all music videos. Not all of these key features appear in every video you see, however it is guaranteed that at least one is present. Goodwin published his thoughts and findings on the subject matter in his book 'Dancing in the Distraction Factory' in 1992.
Lyrics and Visuals
The first feature of a music video, according to Andrew Goodwin, is the relationship between the lyrics in the song and the visuals that appear in the music video:
- Illustrating - where the visuals clearly link with the lyrics
- Amplifying - a more metaphorical way of linking the visuals with the lyrics
- Contradicting - using disjuncture and subverting away from the lyrics having any connection to the visuals in the video
Genre Characteristics
Goodwin came up with the idea that genres exist within music videos, and that certain music videos demonstrated different genre characteristics depending on the genre of music they were produced for. The different types of genres can be divided up into five categories:
- Studio performance
- Stadium performance
- Conceptual/ Experimental
- Location
- Narrative
Goodwin also mentions the post-modern idea of a metanarrative whereby the video or even the lyrics suggest the progression of the artist, taking them from one place to another.
Artist Close Ups
Goodwin expressed that a key feature of music videos is artist close ups. He argued that record companies require and demand that the artist is heavily featured throughout their music videos for the purpose of advertising and marketing. Music videos act as a sort of advertisement for the artist, and often focus heavily on making the artist 'look good' through promoting brand values, unique selling points and artistic style. Videos utilise star iconography to create a recognisable 'artistic brand', buying into the idea of celebrity culture and helping audiences to associate a particular aspect with that artist.
Some artists develop their own motifs that recur throughout their music videos or even take on different personas which help audiences and fans to identify them. There are countless examples of this:
Both Lady Gaga and David Bowie are renowned for their star iconography, star image and use of personas.
Interestingly, however, it is argued that the use of personas and star images can also 'complicate the ability for audiences to recognise the real person underneath the star image construction'. (Devereux, Dillane and Power 2015). Despite this, people associate the image of 'Ziggy Stardust' with David Bowie, and 'Joe Calderone' with Lady Gaga.
Looking and Voyeurism
Voyeurism and the notion of looking are both very broad themes that many music videos feature in some way. The audience will see something in the video that they would not normally see, maybe even in a setting that they would not normally be familiar with, like an intimate scene in a bedroom. Voyeurism can be used to sell the artist's music through sex appeal and can appear in the form of nudity or near nudity, revealing clothes, camera angles and shot types etc. Goodwin makes reference to Laura Mulvey's male gaze theory, particularly when speaking about voyeuruism and the notion of looking and how this attracts a male audience.
Voyeurism can be demonstrated in the form of watching something happening from the eyes of an observer, however it is much more common for the artist to be singing and addressing the audience, creating a false relationship between the artist and the audience that makes them feel connected when in fact this is not true - this is an example of the notion of looking.
Intertextuality
Goodwin points out that another common convention in music videos is intertextuality - referencing other texts such as other music videos, films, books or pop culture. This can be in homage, pastiche or even some kind of brand synergy.
An example of intertextuality in a music video is in Alien Ant Farm's video for their song 'Movies', where they make references to films such as Charlie and The Chocolate Factory and Ghostbusters.
Bibliography
- Goodwin, Andrew. Dancing In The Distraction Factory. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1992. Print.
- Devereux, Eoin, Aileen Dillane, and Martin J Power. David Bowie. Print.
- Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema, GRIN Verlag, 1975, Auth. Laura Mulvey